Tuesday, January 8, 2013
Deport first, ask questions later: 'Fed up' British PM reveals plans to remove terror suspects before they launch appeals
Terror suspects could face a new system of being deported before they get the chance to hold a full appeal, David Cameron revealed yesterday.
The Prime Minister said he was ‘fed up’ with the likes of hate-preacher Abu Qatada using a string of human rights appeals to remain in the UK. Mr Cameron went on: ‘That’s why I’m keen to move to a policy where we deport first, and suspects can appeal later.’
Under this new arrangement, deportees would only be able to appeal against the decision while still in this country - suspending their removal - if they faced ‘a real risk of serious, irreversible harm’.
Currently, nobody can be put on a plane until all their appeals to British courts - and Strasbourg - have been exhausted. The proposals go further than ministers have ever previously suggested.
But last night government officials were unable to provide further details of how the new regime would operate. It was also unclear whether it would apply only to suspected terrorists.
Currently, there are 4,000 foreign rapists, muggers and other criminals walking the streets who the UK cannot kick out.
New rules limited only to the extradition of terror suspects would fall far short of the demands made by Tory MPs for a wide-ranging overhaul of human rights law.
There are also question marks over whether Mr Cameron’s idea would be acceptable to either the Liberal Democrats or, crucially, the European Court of Human Rights.
Ministers would have to explain how, in the event of a terror suspect winning their appeal from overseas, they would be able to locate the terror suspect and bring them back to Britain. Strasbourg has taken a hard-line on removing anybody to a country where torture or ill-treatment takes place.
Qatada’s deportation to Jordan was blocked by Strasbourg on the grounds not that he would be harmed himself, but that some of the evidence used against him may have been obtained by torture. He is currently living in a £400,000 London house - paid for by the taxpayer - pending an appeal by Home Secretary Theresa May.
Last night Tory MP Dominic Raab, who has campaigned to stop the abuse of human rights law by foreign criminals, said: ‘The Prime Minister is absolutely right to embrace fundamental deportation reform.
‘For it to work, we will need an Act of Parliament that lays down the law in clear terms, so ingenious judges with other agendas - at home and in Strasbourg - can’t subvert the common sense system the British public want put in place.’
In October last year, Home Secretary Theresa May said there was a need to reduce ‘the wholly unacceptable delays’ that have occurred in the extradition process for terror suspects. She said there was ‘scope for reforming rights of appeal, streamlining the stages, expediting cases through the court and looking again at the provision of legal aid for terrorist suspects’.
Yesterday, Mr Cameron also voiced frustration with the pace of change on immigration reform, which he said was ‘just an issue where there is quite a profound disagreement between the Liberal Democrats and Conservatives’. The Prime Minister said it is ‘an issue of the absolute centre ground of British politics”
Recent posts at CIS below
See here for the blog. The CIS main page is here.
1. Mark Krikorian Debates Obama Administration's Rule Change on CNBC
2. Op-ed: Would You Buy an Amnesty from These People? Past performance really is an indicator of future results.
3. Migration Enforcement Agency Discourages Funds for Its Own Work
4. A Little Good Immigration Policy News from . . . Oklahoma
5. New Waiver Shields Sponsored Illegal Aliens From Penalties
6. Grover Norquist and Reporters Without Questions
7. Here’s a Sound, if Obscure, Congressional Precedent about Amnesties
8. 'Immigration Reform' – Coming Soon to a Congress Near You
9. Foreign Students Can Still Attend Flight Schools Not Authorized by FAA
10. DREAMers, Conservative Allies Demand Full Amnesty for All Illegal Aliens
11. Cold Water on Globalization
12. Many EB-5 Investments are Marginal – Like that Hockey Team in Phoenix
13. ICE Cancels Enforcement Agreements with 32 Local Partners
14. An Unfortunate Leap
15. "It's an Ill Wind . . . " Hurricane Sandy and TPS for Haitians
16. Walking a Fine Line Between Pastoral Care and Political Activism
17. Pandering on Illegal Immigration Leads to Defeat
18. Mexico's El Universal Says Latinos in U.S. Have No Civil Rights
19. As We Face a "Fiscal Cliff" Let's Close Immigration-Related Tax Loopholes
20. H-1B Victims Win Symbolic but Hollow Victory in U.S. District Court
21. NPR Fudges the Facts on Border Security
22. DHS Gives Criminal Alien Privacy but Snubs Victim
23. Who Comes First, the Inventor or the Casino Investor?
24. ICE Exercises Prosecutorial Discretion for ID Fraud
25. It's a Sealed Court Document, But if You Cross My Palm with Silver . . .
26. Why Scrap the Per-Country Cap?
27. Amnesty's Impact on Health Resources
28. Obama's Illegal Amnesty Continues
Posted by jonjayray at 10:25 AM